Saxon Math vs Singapore Math
Two legendary math curricula with completely different philosophies. Here's how to pick the right one for your family.
📑 In This Comparison
⚡ Quick Verdict
🏆 Choose Saxon If...
Your child needs constant review and repetition, you want a scripted/open-and-go curriculum, or you're not confident teaching math yourself. Saxon's incremental approach prevents gaps.
🏆 Choose Singapore If...
Your child is strong in math or needs conceptual depth, you want to build true number sense, or you're comfortable supplementing with practice problems. Produces exceptional problem-solvers.
📊 Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Saxon Math | Singapore Math |
|---|---|---|
| Teaching Approach | Incremental with constant review (spiral) | Mastery-based with visual models (CPA approach) |
| Best Learning Style | Sequential learners, those who need repetition | Visual learners, conceptual thinkers |
| Parent Involvement | Low-Medium (scripted lessons) | Medium-High (requires understanding method) |
| Academic Rigor | 7/10 - Solid, procedural | 9/10 - Exceptional depth |
| Ease of Use | 9/10 - Very easy to implement | 6/10 - Learning curve for parents |
| Problem-Solving | Adequate - more procedural | Excellent - builds deep reasoning |
| Grade Range | K-12 (full coverage) | K-8 (strongest in elementary) |
| Special Needs | Good for ADHD (structure) | Challenging for processing issues |
| Cost (Per Year) | $80-$120 | $100-$180 |
🔍 Detailed Breakdown
1. Teaching Philosophy
Saxon uses an incremental, spiral approach. Each lesson introduces a small concept, then reviews 20-30 problems from previous lessons. Kids never forget because they're constantly practicing everything. It's systematic and predictable—some kids thrive on this, others find it tedious.
Singapore uses the Concrete-Pictorial-Abstract (CPA) approach developed in Singapore, whose students consistently rank #1 in international math tests. Kids start with physical manipulatives, move to visual bar models, then abstract numbers. This builds genuine understanding rather than just procedure.
Bottom line: Saxon teaches kids to DO math. Singapore teaches kids to UNDERSTAND math.
2. Daily Lesson Structure
Saxon (K-3): Meeting time (calendar, counting), lesson with manipulatives, worksheet with fact practice. About 30-45 minutes total.
Saxon (4-12): Read lesson, complete mixed problem set (30 problems covering old and new material). About 45-60 minutes.
Singapore: Short teaching time with textbook, practice problems in workbook, mental math exercises. About 30-45 minutes, but requires more parent teaching.
3. What Parents Say
Saxon fans say: "My kid never forgets anything because of the constant review." "I don't have to plan—I just open and teach." "Finally a math curriculum my struggling learner can succeed with."
Singapore fans say: "My kids can solve problems they've never seen before." "Math finally makes sense to my visual learner." "They're doing math 2 grades ahead because they actually understand the concepts."
Common complaints: Saxon can feel repetitive and boring for quick learners. Singapore requires parents to understand the method, and some kids need more practice than the workbook provides.
Sources: Well-Trained Mind Forums · Cathy Duffy Reviews
4. Long-Term Outcomes
Saxon produces students who are solid, procedurally fluent, and well-prepared for standardized tests. The constant review means fewer gaps. However, they may struggle with novel problem types that require flexible thinking.
Singapore produces students with exceptional number sense and problem-solving ability. They excel at word problems and can apply math to new situations. However, some students may need additional fact practice for fluency.
5. The Switch Factor
Switching TO Saxon: Usually easy. Kids may find the repetition refreshing if they had gaps. Start a grade back and move quickly through review.
Switching TO Singapore: Can be challenging. The bar model method is different, and kids without it may struggle with word problems. Consider using the "Challenging Word Problems" supplement to catch up on the method.
6. High School Pathways
Saxon: Complete K-12 sequence including Algebra 1, Algebra 2, Geometry, Advanced Math, and Calculus. Many families use Saxon through graduation.
Singapore: Ends after 8th grade. Most families transition to Art of Problem Solving, Saxon, or another curriculum for Algebra and beyond. This isn't a weakness—Singapore's goal is to build the foundation.
🎯 Best For Scenarios
✅ Choose Saxon Math For:
- Kids who need structure and routine
- Students who forget material easily
- Families wanting an open-and-go curriculum
- Parents not confident in math
- Kids with ADHD who need predictability
- Students preparing for standardized tests
- Those who want one curriculum K-12
- Kids who work independently (grades 5+)
✅ Choose Singapore Math For:
- Visual and conceptual learners
- Gifted or math-talented students
- Kids who ask "why?" constantly
- Families prioritizing problem-solving skills
- Students bored by repetition
- Those wanting deep mathematical understanding
- Future STEM-oriented students
- Parents comfortable teaching math
💰 Price Comparison (Per Grade Level)
Saxon Math
Singapore Math
Both curricula are reusable with additional children (non-consumable textbooks). Singapore workbooks are consumable.
📌 Our Final Recommendation
There's no "better" curriculum—only the better fit for YOUR child. Saxon is the reliable workhorse that will never leave gaps. Singapore is the thoroughbred that builds exceptional mathematical thinkers.
If you're still unsure: Try Singapore first. If your child struggles with the conceptual approach or you find it overwhelming to teach, switch to Saxon. You can always come back to Singapore methods later.
Links may be affiliate links. We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep reviews unbiased and free.
Related Comparisons
Still exploring math options? Check out these comparisons:
- Browse All Math Curricula
- RightStart Math Review (another hands-on option)
- Take Our Curriculum Quiz